Monday, April 16, 2018

Why Building the Trans Mountain Pipeline Will Increase Gas Prices in B.C.

Why Building the Trans Mountain Pipeline Will Increase Gas Prices in B.C.

By Robyn Allan • Wednesday, March 28, 2018 - 13:29
Last week gasoline prices soared in southern B.C., with the price at the pump in Vancouver hitting over $1.55 per litre. This was not due to a restriction of supply, although Alberta Premier Rachel Notley jumped on the opportunity to once again misrepresent reality in order to draw erroneous conclusions supporting the need for Kinder Morgan's Trans Mountain expansion.
"There are a lot of ways in which the province of B.C. can assure an adequate supply of gasoline in order to combat the ridiculous prices that they pay," Notley said in Calgary last week.
If B.C. wanted to keep gasoline prices low, she said, it should stop opposing the Kinder Morgan oil pipeline expansion as it would increase "the ability of Alberta to ship more product to the West."
Notley assumes B.C. needs more crude oil to supply the Parkland refinery in Burnaby and more refined petroleum product to supply the retail outlets that Parkland's refinery does not. She also assumes that building Trans Mountain's expansion means Alberta's oil producers and refiners will ship more product to B.C. Neither assumption is correct.
Let's review the facts.

High gas prices are not due to a shortage of supply.

Gas prices are not high because of a lack of supply. There is plenty of supply to serve the B.C. market.
High gas prices are the result of a decades old strategy in Alberta to charge what the market will bear, not charge based on the costs of production and delivery (including a reasonable return on investment) as would be the case in a well-functioning market. This unfair or predatory pricing is sometimes referred to as price gouging. This reality exists to varying degrees all across Canada, although it is more prevalent in Lower Mainland and Vancouver Island markets.
Every time the pain at the pumps from this inappropriate pricing practice becomes obvious, it appears industry apologists are standing at the ready to trot out phoney "reasons" for the increase in gas prices.
The facts show B.C. exports more gasoline than it imports. Port of Vancouver statistics reveal that during 2017, exports to the U.S. exceeded imports by almost 70 per cent, giving rise to net gasoline exports of 6,000 barrels a day. There is no supply shortage in B.C. — chronic or otherwise.

Kinder Morgan's new pipeline will not increase the shipment of product to B.C.

Trans Mountain's expansion is intended to ship 540,000 barrels a day of diluted bitumen — heavy oil — to the Westridge dock for offshore export. None of this crude is destined for B.C.
The Parkland refinery already receives all the light crude oil it can refine from the existing pipeline so there is no shortage there. Further, the refinery is not configured to use heavy oil like diluted bitumen from the oilsands. This is why a heavy oil pipeline through B.C. is of no benefit to B.C.
As far as refined product is concerned, Kinder Morgan's business case for the Trans Mountain pipeline is explicitly based on no increase in crude oil or refined product supply to B.C.
Kinder Morgan told the National Energy Board (NEB) that "refined product shipments will not increase as a result of [the Trans Mountain Expansion Project]."
Unfair pricing at the pump will not change no matter what happens with the Trans Mountain expansion because it is not due to a scarcity of supply. Addressing the failure of the market to fairly determine gasoline prices requires policy direction from government and meaningful regulation.

If the Trans Mountain expansion is built, B.C.'s gas prices will increase.

We know regional gas prices will rise if Trans Mountain's expansion proceeds because the NEB approved an increase in toll rates on the existing pipeline that guarantees it. The board gave Kinder Morgan permission to more than double the cost of delivering a barrel of gasoline or diesel to B.C. motorists on the existing pipeline in order to help pay for the new one.
Higher transportation costs on the existing line will ratchet up pump prices. Producers and refiners consider increased transportation costs a cost of doing business and they get passed onto end-users.
Trans Mountain's expansion — a heavy oil pipeline Notley maintains is for the benefit of offshore markets in Asia — is not commercially viable unless B.C. consumers and businesses subsidize it through higher gas prices here at home.

Big Oil needs B.C.'s market demand more than B.C. needs Alberta's refined product.

Notley has threatened B.C. with an ultimatum — stop resisting the expansion or face serious supply restriction. But her threat to "turn off the taps" is idle.
Kinder Morgan and Alberta's oil producers and refiners will not allow this kind of behaviour. It would send shock waves through the international business community and will fundamentally cost Alberta's oil sector more than it will cost B.C.
B.C. is an important market for Alberta's refiners and light oil producers.
If supply from Trans Mountain is shut off, the Parkland refinery can turn to offshore crude while other retail distribution systems can seek imported refined product — likely at lower prices if existing supply agreements are rendered invalid through Alberta legislated restrictions. A marine terminal to deliver jet fuel to the Vancouver International Airport is in the process of being constructed with the expressed purpose of being able to access jet fuel supply at lower cost from numerous markets.

Turning off the taps in B.C. would flood the Prairies and end up costing Alberta's refinery sector.

Since the Trans Mountain pipeline delivers gas from Edmonton refineries to B.C., if supply were to be curtailed, downward pressure on retail prices in Prairie markets would mount because of a corresponding over-supply there.
That would mean every barrel supplied in Alberta would take some hit — not just the barrels diverted from B.C.
In order to limit supply in one market without a corresponding loss, there needs to be demand in another. The demand is not there.
Which companies are poised to take the hit in Alberta? Suncor, Imperial and Shell.
Suncor is poised for a double whammy. Suncor is the major shipper of refined gasoline and diesel product to B.C. along Trans Mountain for sale in Petro-Canada stations, but also under agreement with other retail outlets.
There is little likelihood Suncor will break contracts and destroy long-term business relationships with others in B.C. undermining not only its short-term, but long-term profitability in order to support Notley's political posturing.

Kinder Morgan has too much to lose if shipments along its pipeline are curtailed — including the ability to finance its project.

Notley has not connected the dots between Kinder Morgan Canada Limited's (KML) revenue stream and the company's ability to proceed with the Trans Mountain expansion, either.
Current toll rates charged on the existing pipeline provide a significant portion of the company's cash flow. It is not trivial.
Interrupting Kinder Morgan Canada's revenue stream by limiting supply impedes the company's ability to pay dividends to its shareholders. This not only hurts Canadian investors, it particularly hurts Kinder Morgan's 's Texas-based parent Kinder Morgan Inc. (KMI) in Houston.
Kinder Morgan senior still owns 70 per cent of the Canadian company. KMI needs dividends from the Canadian operations to support its ongoing financial challenges. An interruption of Trans Mountain's existing revenue stream would get in the way of KMI's cash flow needs .
Interruption of Trans Mountain's existing revenue stream, by limiting pipeline shipments, would also impede Kinder Morgan Canada's ability to pay dividends on its $550 million in outstanding preferred shares.
As well, Kinder Morgan Canada still needs to raise more than $2 billion in equity capital to help finance its expansion. Try going to financial markets to raise risk capital while revenues are impaired because of a legislated election ploy.
Finally, if reduced cash flow from "turning off the taps" — even just a little bit — causes a credit rating downgrade for the Canadian operations, Canada's big banks could pull their $5.5 billion construction loan facility. Without the credit facility keeping the expansion afloat, the Trans Mountain expansion sinks.
Image: Todd Bigelow / Aurora Photos

Measure
Measure
Evernote helps you remember everything and get organized effortlessly. Download Evernote.

‘Last Stand’ Film Documents B.C.’s Role In Accelerating Demise of Mountain Caribou

'Last Stand' Film Documents B.C.'s Role In Accelerating Demise of Mountain Caribou

By Judith Lavoie • Wednesday, April 11, 2018 - 09:30
Images courtesy of David Moskowitz.
Film producer, biologist and wildlife photographer David Moskowitz was shocked to find that old-growth logging is continuing in B.C.'s interior temperate rainforest, despite clear evidence that it threatens fragile herds of endangered mountain caribou and, as he worked on his latest film, he tried to figure out how caribou and ancient trees could be saved, while protecting the local economy.
There is no simple solution, said Moskowitz, but he is hoping his film, "Last Stand: The Vanishing Caribou Rainforest," which will be playing at the ELEMENTS film festival at Science World in Vancouver this weekend, will make people aware of what is at stake.
Last Stand will play Sunday afternoon as a part of the film festival's Beautiful B.C. segment, that features short films A Northern Path: Exploring the Nisga'a and Stewart-Cassiar Highways and I Am Salmon as well as Creekwalker, a feature-length film that traces the creeks of the Great Bear Rainforest.
"[Last Stand] is about the last and largest remaining inland temperate rainforest on Planet Earth and these amazing creatures, the mountain caribou, that are tied to this ecosystem and how we are continuing to destroy it through logging and resource extraction," he told DeSmog Canada.
The population of mountain caribou now stands at about 1,500 animals in a dozen herds that roam between the Kootenays and U.S. Pacific Northwest and they are struggling to survive, said Moskowitz, who worked on the film for about two-and-a-half years with director Colin Arisman.
"The whole population is at risk of extinction right now and the key part of this story is that B.C. and Canada have refused to take any substantive action to stop destroying the habitat for these animals," he said.
"The reason these animals are disappearing is that humans have destroyed their refuge habitat, which is old-growth forest…They are turning old-growth trees into toilet paper."
As forests are destroyed other species such as deer move in, followed by more predators and produces the conundrum of how to keep the mountain caribou alive while protecting First Nations culture and a forest economy, Moskowitz said.
In addition to the shock of finding B.C. is continuing to harvest timber in unique old-growth ecosystems, Moskowitz was stunned to discover that logging is subsidized by government because it costs companies more to get the trees to market than they get from selling them.
The province also mandates how much companies must cut, stipulating they will lose their licence if they do not harvest enough, he said.
"There is an imperative for them to keep cutting, regardless of the economics," he said.
Marcus Reynerson inspects the mountain caribou tracks along the banks of a lake in the Canadian Rockies. Photo by David Moskowitz
There is little old-growth logging on the U.S. side of the border, but that does not necessarily mean the U.S. has done a better job, Moskowitz said.
"We had a few decades head-start, so there's a lot less to cut. The opportunities to salvage this ecosystem is north of the border, but it is slated to be logged over the next four decades…Where the rubber meets the road is Canada and B.C.," he said.
Moskowitz does not pretend he has solutions, but the film looks at topics such as community forestry and value-added forestry, where, rather than exporting pulp, jobs are created in local paper mills.
"Conservation initiatives that don't work for local people just don't work. Period. Some of the changes that need to take place in forestry would have a huge impact on the local economy," he said.
"But we could cut a whole lot less trees and employ just as many people, if not more, if we looked at a value-added economy."
Moskowitz hopes that one message that will resonate with audiences is that human beings cannot not turn away from the mess they have created.
"Climate change is going to change this ecosystem which is going to set in motion cascading ecological issues where we have increased some species numbers, which affects predators, which affects endangered species. We can't take our fingers out of this pie," he said.
"We have made a mess of things and we can't just stay out of it. We must stay engaged and make really difficult choices."
The ELEMENTS film festival will feature nature, wildlife and conservation films from 11 countries April 14-15 at the Telus World of Science in Vancouver.
Image: A logger in mountain caribou habitat. Photo: David Moskowitz. See more of Moskowitz's photography on Instagram: @moskowitz_david

Kinder Morgan is Blackmailing Canada and the Government is Letting it Happen

Kinder Morgan is Blackmailing Canada and the Government is Letting it Happen

By Andrew Nikiforuk • Thursday, April 12, 2018 - 09:43
This article originally appeared in The Tyee.
Kinder Morgan's decision to suspend work on its controversial $7.4-billion Trans Mountain pipeline looks like a another corporate attempt to blackmail Canadian governments.
On Sunday the Texas-based company, which emerged from the ashes of scandal-ridden Enron, abruptly announced it was suspending all "non-essential" work on the export pipeline.
Steve Kean, CEO of Kinder Morgan Canada, blamed the B.C. government for the suspension — even though the National Energy Board has not approved construction for any portion of the project but the Westridge marine terminal in Burnaby. 
Even Kinder Morgan has repeatedly acknowledged the reality of setbacks in presentations to investors, citing "a potential unmitigated project delay to December 2020" as recently as last month.
Still, Kean blamed B.C. "What we have is a government that is openly in opposition and has reaffirmed that opposition very recently," he said. 
But aren't democracies supposed to challenge projects that impose unprecedented economic and environment risks on their citizens?
Wouldn't a tanker spill of diluted bitumen in the Salish Sea, where one-third of western Canada's population lives, be an economic and environmental catastrophe, devastating tourism, property values and marine life?
Wouldn't the doubling of tolls on the expanded pipeline, as approved by the National Energy Board, raise gas prices for British Columbian motorists by $100 million a year? The pipeline now supplies southern B.C. with most of its petroleum.
Won't Alberta, by exporting diluted bitumen to Asian refineries, repeat the original Canadian sin of failing to add value to resources at home, giving up thousands of jobs and billions in revenue?
How can exporting one of the world's most carbon intensive fuels help fight climate change? 
And can't corporations with viable projects accommodate citizens, courts, First Nations and economists who think such costs and liabilities should be properly accounted for?
But Kinder Morgan prefers bluster and blackmail instead of the reality that the project was never a sound venture because it was about privatizing gains and socializing costs. 
Economist Robyn Allan has repeatedly argued that Kinder Morgan is no ordinary company and the Trans Mountain expansion project has been uneconomic since day one.
She told The Tyee that "Kinder Morgan is looking for an exit strategy, but it likely includes a need to demonize Ottawa in order to set the stage for a suit under NAFTA."
The drama begins with the biased workings of the National Energy Board, which refused to look at downstream and upstream climate impacts of the project and even failed to scrutinize its commercial viability during public hearings.
The best evidence from experts shows that Kinder Morgan, the Canadian government and Notley have misrepresented the pipeline's illusory benefits.
A pipeline to the coast will not raise bitumen prices, because all global markets discount junk crude due to its poor quality.
The ill-conceived project will export refining jobs and great clouds of climate-changing emissions to China. In addition tanker traffic place southern resident orcas at risk.
The Houston-based firm that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Alberta Premier Rachel Notley now salute as a defender of Canada's national interest is the spawn of Enron, found guilty of accounting fraud and corruption. The energy trader's collapse cost shareholders $74 billion and killed 20,000 jobs.
Kinder Morgan, a dirty and unsexy mover of gas and oil, began as Enron Liquids Pipeline in 1997. Enron alumni continue to populate the senior ranks of Kinder Morgan.
They include Richard Kinder, a Texas billionaire and Kinder Morgan's chair. He worked at Enron for 16 years. Jordan Mintz, the chief tax officer, served as the vice-president of Enron's tax division from 1996-2000.
Kean, the man now baiting Canadian governments, worked as Enron's senior vice-president of government affairs. And so on.
These Enron alumni probably think Canadian politicians are the ultimate pushovers and dimwits.
During the 2014 NEB Trans Mountain hearings the U.S. parent firm vowed to provide 100 per cent of the debt and equity for the pipeline.
But after a Wall Street analyst suggested the third largest energy company in North America wasn't spending enough to maintain its pipelines or returning value to investors, the company's share price fell. Kinder Morgan's stock value plummeted in 2015 and continues to languish. Lower oil prices and rising debt put its largest capital project on shaky ground. 
Allan says investors recognized a year ago that the Trans Mountain project didn't make commercial sense. As investor interest waned, Allan said, Kinder Morgan couldn't raise debt or equity in the U.S. markets or find a joint-venture partner.
The job of raising money for the project then fell to Kinder Morgan Canada. But $1.6 billion it raised in 2017 went to pay off debts of its parent company.
Richard Kinder explained the move in a conference call with investors: "So we were able to strengthen KMI'S balance sheet using the IPO proceeds to pay down debt… " 
Kinder Morgan Canada has arranged $5.5 billion in construction facility loans from Canadian banks — but only if Kinder Morgan raises $2 billion in equity for the project.
"And now we learn from Premier Notley and Kinder Morgan Canada CEO Steven Kean that conversations with Alberta for financial support have taken place," says Allan.
Rachel Notley, Canada's leading petro politician, apparently can't wait to pour taxpayers' money into a project that the market views as high risk and that British Columbians regard as a threat to their best interests.
"Alberta is prepared to do whatever it takes to get this pipeline built — including taking a public position in the pipeline," Notley said Sunday.
So corporate blackmail works like a charm in Canada.
Allan says Kinder Morgan is looking for a way out.
"The project is not commercially viable and, even before it's built, Kinder Morgan is looking for a bailout," she said. "If Kinder Morgan's long-term contracts for moving 700,000 barrels of bitumen and oil on a controversial pipeline were solid, would Kinder Morgan now be blaming the government of B.C. for its problems?"
In a normal world governments concerned about fiscal prudence and the public interest would let Kinder Morgan abandon a non-viable project. (Some analysts have already said cancelling the project would be a "significant blow," but not "the end of the world for Kinder Morgan.")
In a moral world Canadian governments would admit that pipelines and tankers export refinery jobs and greenhouse gas emissions on a disastrous scale.
In a just world Alberta would have to admit it has allowed industry to overproduce bitumen due to low royalties and bad governance. The province has no strategic plan for bitumen other than screaming for pipelines.
But Canada, like its southern neighbour, is having trouble behaving normally, morally or justly these days.
But Trudeau and Notley think it's OK to embrace a debt-ridden U.S. company so it can export, via tankers, unrefined bitumen to Chinese refineries where the upgraded resource can enrich the authoritarian Communist party.
Canadians should be more than ashamed.
They should be alarmed.
Image: Justin Trudeau speaks to B.C. media about oil spill response and the Kinder Morgan pipeline, April 5, 2018 Photo: Carol Linnitt | DeSmog Canada
Evernote helps you remember everything and get organized effortlessly. Download Evernote.

The New Jazz Torchbearer: Kamasi Washington on His Musical Message

The New Jazz Torchbearer: Kamasi Washington on His Musical Message

Hailed as a primary architect of a West Coast jazz revival, the creative genius has also been an integral part of Kendrick Lamar's last two albums
Presented by
Despite all the hosannas he's garnered up to this point  – being hailed as a primary architect of a West Coast jazz revival, featured in the Whitney Museum's prestigious Biennial and playing to thousands at Coachella – Kamasi Washington, 37, doesn't see himself as the guy. Sure, he was an integral part of Kendrick Lamar's last two albums (arranging strings and playing tenor sax on To Pimp a Butterfly and Damn.), and yeah, his strain of spiritual jazz helped rejuvenate the genre. But to hear him tell it, he's merely living in the moment. "I'm a messenger," he says simply. "So now that people are listening, I see it as an opportunity to offer more messages."

Related


Inside Kamasi Washington's New Ode to Unity
Saxophonist/composer on how the troubled state of America inspired Whitney Biennial multimedia piece 'Harmony of Difference'
It took a long time for him to make it to this point. As a budding musician, Washington and his friends would practice in his parents' garage in Inglewood, in a small space called "The Shack," not far from the LAX landing strip. There, he and the West Coast Get Down – an outstanding collective of musicians that included virtuoso bassist Stephen "Thundercat" Bruner, trombonist Ryan Porter, and pianist Cameron Graves – would work in cramped conditions and sweltering heat, cultivating their vision of the future.
Washington supported himself a touring musician – spending several years in the bands of Snoop Dogg, Chaka Khan and others – but he and the West Coast Get Down focused on jazz at a time when it wasn't popular in mainstream music, when it was considered archaic and relegated to smaller clubs. They crew kept at it, even as the world outside the Shack spiraled out of control.
In 2015, Washington released his debut album, The Epic, an explosive three-hour set that touched on decades of tradition — from gospel and big-band jazz to funk — and fused the skronking 1960s psychedelic essence of Pharoah Sanders, Sun Ra and John Coltrane with thefeel-good sounds of Seventies fusion, the last time jazz connected with a mainstream audience. The Epic arrived two months after Lamar's Butterfly, at a time of intense racial struggle in the United States, and its themes of peace and unity were especially resonant for black Americans. Washington's record was meant to help heal a community still grieving the deaths of unarmed black males at the hands of law enforcement. Two years later – on 2017's Harmony of Difference, which debuted at the Whitney Biennial – Washington explored counterpoint, with versions of the same melody appearing in each of the EP's six songs. "My hope is that witnessing the beautiful harmony created by merging different musical melodies will help people realize the beauty in our own differences," he said in a statement at the time. The new material that he's been working on – a new LP, Heaven and Earth, is due out in June – marries the big-band aesthetics of The Epic and Harmony of Difference with the sort of darker, spacier tones heard on landmark works of exploration like Albert Ayler's Spiritual Unity or Miles Davis' Live-Evil. 

Related


Kamasi Washington Previews LP 'Heaven and Earth' With Two New Songs
"The Space Travelers Lullaby," new arrangement of "Fists of Fury" theme to appear on jazz saxophonist's follow-up to 2015 album 'The Epic'
To that end, Washington's music never addresses the social climate head on; it's shaded by world events but doesn't wallow in them. "They affect me deeply, but I try not to let it consume me," he says. "Someone like Donald Trump can't control the way I show love to my brother. He can't control the way I feel about my neighbors. I'm trying to make the music bigger than the politics. If you get caught up in the day-to-day, you'll get lost in that."

Washington's art seeks a higher vibration, beyond the despair and provocative tweets. As people separate themselves along racial and political lines, Washington wants you to see the good in humanity, the childlike innocence buried beneath the callus of pain and distrust. His approach is heard on cathartic songs like "The Rhythm Changes" and the volcanic "Askim." It's in the majestic swing of "Humility" and the kaleidoscopic "Truth." Songs like those are why Washington is the most talked-about musician in mainstream jazz, and why—regardless of the abundant work he's released so far—the composer is just getting started. "I feel like I'm musically free to do what I want," Washington says. "I'm coming into a place where I'm saying what I want with my instrument."


Measure
Measure
Evernote helps you remember everything and get organized effortlessly. Download Evernote.